Effective global leaders carry within them the capacity to transform the fortunes of the organizations they serve. Entire workforces can be mobilized to unite behind a common purpose and take ownership of the destiny of the organization as a whole.
Finding examples of when leaders fail to deliver this kind of transformation is reasonably easy to do. Studying those different scenarios has value because we can glean so many different lessons from what went wrong. But it’s just as impactful to see remarkable examples of when global leadership is discharged effectively.
Enter Carlos Ghosn.
Carlos Ghosn is a man who managed to do the impossible (or what many claimed to be the impossible). In a nation where traditions are honored and actively defended, he managed to get a large company to completely overhaul their strategy and modify longstanding customs that were holding them back.
After 20 years of leadership, Ghosn is now in the middle of a financial misconduct investigation. His reputation is, for the time being, in tatters. But, what is becoming clear, is his exceptional abilities as a global leader. His achievements are highlighted even more as it becomes evident that his successors lack the skill to take Nissan into a new era.
So how did Carlos Ghosn do it? What can global leaders learn from his example? Read on for a goldmine of thoughts around one of the greatest turnarounds in automotive history.
As previously stated, we are aware of the negative media currently surrounding Carlos Ghosn as he awaits trial on financial misconduct charges in Japan. The situation will surely unravel over time. Whether the allegations are true or not, aspiring global leaders can learn from Ghosn’s actions when he took over Nissan. This article serves the purpose of looking at his accomplishments as a global leader in the past, without judging them negatively or positively, but by laying out the facts.
Nissan: The Company Innovation Forgot
Nissan had enjoyed steady growth and prosperity since the end of the second world war. Known for producing quality cars that combined great engineering, the latest tech, and plenty of fuel efficiency. After putting a few designs out into that market that had global success, Nissan became content to ride the wave of that success.
Customer appetites started to change; people wanted not just reliable cars but beautiful cars with great design and all the latest technology. Rather than innovating in response to these customer demands, Nissan assumed that reliability still took precedence over style so they did not invest in creating new designs.
In addition to this the ‘keiretsu’, a group of preferred suppliers for the car components, meant that finding competitive pricing to reduce the cost of manufacturing was not a priority. Nissan’s costs to produce a car was 20 – 25% higher than it was for Renault. The whole process was inefficient and contributed to Nissan not being profitable for several years. When the Japanese Yen devalued from 100¥ to $1 to 90¥ to $1, both Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s announced that Nissan needed a cash injection from another automotive company or their credit status would be significantly downgraded. Things were looking pretty dire, to say the least.
Renault and Nissan: A Juggernaut Partnership
Both Renault and Nissan had a desire to expand their global reach. Renault wanted to decrease its reliance on the European market and expand into the Asian and North American markets. Renault was also doing well in the Latin American market, particularly in Brazil. Nissan had a great share in the Asian and North American markets but wanted to expand into Latin America. They couldn’t because they didn’t have the distribution facilities.
By forming a strategic alliance, they hoped to share best practice and balance out access to all the major markets across the world.
Ghosn: The Man With A Plan
Brazilian-born French executive Carlos Ghosn with Lebanese ancestry has become known as one of the automobile industry’s great turnaround artists. Dubbed “le cost killer” by those on the receiving end of his streamlining, he also had a more positive and more telling nickname: “Mr. Fix-It.”
Before working for Renault, Ghosn was head of research for the development of industrial tires at Michelin in the mid-1980s, where he worked his way up to become president and chief operating officer (CEO) of North America by 1988. After adding the position of chairman in 1990, there were no more advancement possibilities for him to at Michelin, and he started looking elsewhere. In 1996, he therefore agreed to talk to Louis Schweitzer, CEO of the money-losing French automaker Renault.
Ghosn started working for a contrite Renault after the merger with Volvo failed to materialize. He’d done an extensive amount of work turning around Renault’s fortunes. As part of the strategic alliance, Ghosn agreed to take the post of COO and work on producing a similar transformation for the Japanese car company.
Carlos Ghosn knew that Nissan had the potential to really gain back the ground they had lost and more. So he put together the plan that would catapult Nissan straight back onto the map.
After a six-month consultation, during which Nissan employees themselves completed a review of operations company-wide, Ghosn presented the ‘Nissan Revival Plan’ (NRP). This plan aimed to focus on the following:
- Developing new markets and new cars with a greater emphasis on design
- Improving and reviving Nissan’s brand image
- Kickstarting an investment plan for research and development
- Reducing the costs of production
In addition to this, Ghosn reorganized the company structure from top to bottom, removing positions that served no purpose and redirecting human resources elsewhere. He put in place a rewards package that encouraged employees to come up with new ideas, thereby reversing the previous culture where everybody did their utmost to avoid making a mistake.
Before the NRP came into effect, seniority drove promotion. Ghosn turned that on its head and made room for younger employees to be promoted above older employees. There was excitement to contribute again. So much excitement that the NRP was completed within two years. Costs had been reduced by 20%, and for the first time in years, Nissan was profitable again.
Ghosn didn’t stop there. A month later, ‘Nissan 180’ pushed a new customer-focused initiative to transition the company out of the previous plan. Now Nissan would focus on making their products more attractive, more reliable and they would also focus on improving the whole customer experience.
In a short summary of the situation, it’s easy to believe that things were simple enough. However, the fact that Ghosn made the transformation look easy, doesn’t mean that it was.
Let’s look at some of the main challenges Ghosn faced as he took Nissan through the process.
The Challenge of Complacency
Ghosn’s greatest challenge was undoubtedly the complacency across the whole of Nissan’s operations from the top of the organization right down to the bottom. Cashflow was tied up in investments that weren’t necessarily the best, suppliers took advantage of the fact that they were on a preferred supplier list and kept prices high. The “job for a lifetime” ethos meant that everybody assumed that the Japanese government wouldn’t let the company go down in flames.
Decisions were taking forever to be made. Whilst the need to collaborate was respectable, the constant need for consensus meant that many projects that could have moved the business forward were forever stuck in the planning phase. Review after review would happen, and no concrete decision would be reached.
In addition to this, there were huge issues around a distinct lack of risk-taking; those within the company who wanted to further their careers did so by maintaining the status quo and avoiding all forms of risk-taking. People were being promoted simply because they had been there the longest number of years; not always a problem but it did mean that young talent was not utilized as it could have been.
Once Nissan recognized that the situation wasn’t great, a culture of blame ensued. It was always the other department’s fault. A survey was taken and every single department believed that the company was not doing as well as it should be because of other departments and that they were doing everything that they should be doing.
Ghosn parachuted into this situation and everybody expected him to fail. He was open about the fact that he was not knowledgeable about Japanese culture when he first started on the assignment. He was a foreigner. He had a reputation for finding ways to slash costs. He would have to make some very difficult decisions that would involve bringing in outside help into the senior leadership team whilst displacing some of the longstanding Japanese senior executives. He faced backlash from the press who believed him to be yet another foreigner trying to impose their ideals on Japan…again.
So you can imagine everyone’s surprise when Ghosn took Nissan and Renault from strength to strength… for 20 years.
Why Did Ghosn Succeed?
Ghosn drew from a whole host of internal attributes that enabled him to bring two entirely different economies, two companies, and two cultures together under one banner. There are several key things he did to achieve this.
Culturally Transcendent Leadership
Ghosn made it clear that he had a leadership philosophy that was applicable in any context. This gave him a really strong foundation because his leadership style was almost completely untouched by any cultural bias. By choosing three core pillars as a leadership style that nobody could disagree with, he automatically put himself into a place where people from different cultures worldwide would respect him. Who doesn’t want to work for a management team that’s
- transparent,
- focused on great communication, and
- excited to execute on a plan.
It was a very smart thing to do and contributed a great deal to his ability to transform the companies he worked for.
Excellent Interpersonal Skills
Ghosn was an expert communicator with very advanced interpersonal skills. He negotiated a merger between Renault and Nissan that allowed Nissan to retain everything it stood for as a brand. As a Brazilian-born Frenchman of Lebanese descent, Ghosn had a knack for moving seamlessly between different cultures and different people across all levels of any organization he was a part of. Having an appreciation for lots of different contexts allowed him to develop his interpersonal skills and build great relationships with people from all over the world.
He was known for being great at interacting with employees; he was always the person to visit the plants and greet people. He made a point of being visible and accessible to the wider team, choosing to champion the importance of warm micro-interactions that made employees feel valued and interconnected.
His whole approach was to empower the Nissan teams to become masters of their own destiny and shape the success of the company. By pulling in middle managers, he created opportunities for them to grow and develop. Teaming was a skill that Ghosn was exceptional at. So many factors were in a constant state of flux; the subsequent job losses that came, new suppliers, new designs, new leadership… the list went on. Despite this, Ghosn was able to keep everybody laser-focused on achieving the goal of profitability and increased market share.
Cultural Intelligence
There’s no denying that Ghosn was really adept at learning about all the cultures he interacted with in order to be an effective leader. Learning about Japanese culture was half the battle. The real genius was how he took all of his cultural experience and weaved a culture tapestry in the midst of what many people deemed to be an impossible situation. To bring together French and Japanese culture under one banner was no mean feat.
Clear Vision
At all points, the vision put forward by Ghosn was clearly defined and easy for everybody to understand. When the company met its objectives early, Ghosn was ready with the next challenge to keep everybody engaged and moving forward.
Compelling Story
The hardest part of turning Nissan around was getting the organization as a whole to understand that change was necessary. Everybody needed a wake-up call. Ghosn’s ability to take a timely story and use it to get everybody focused was a stroke of genius not to be underestimated.
Collaborative Culture
Creating a collaborative culture was one of the best things Ghosn did. The vision was fixed but the execution needed to come from the teams themselves. As Ghosn was not particular about how they should execute the vision, he created the space for everybody to come together and design a plan that they all agreed with. Ghosn transitioned Nissan teams from being separate entities wrapped up in blame culture and responsibility denial, to interdependent teams that took almost complete ownership over the action plan to save Nissan from destruction.
Lesson 1 for Global Leaders: Master a Transcendent Leadership Style
Global leaders should build a leadership style based on universal core values. Ghosn cracked a particular formula that was an excellent springboard for being able to mobilize and inspire people regardless of culture. Imagine then adding all of the other competencies required of a global leader; you’ll be able to operate in practically any context.
Ghosn picked three principles that he felt were important; transparency, a commitment to executing the plan, and communication. You may want to include all of those and nothing else or include different principles tailored specifically to your context. Either way, these principles will bridge the gap as you learn all the nuances of the cultures you seek to bring together and enable you to inspire the workforce to get on board with the changes you want to execute.
Lesson 2: Always Develop Your Interpersonal Skills
Interpersonal skills are key. Being able to get people onside was one of Ghosn’s key tactics in negotiating one of the most difficult deals in automotive history. As a global leader be sure to engage with employees at all levels of the business and be visible.
Don’t be afraid to empower your teams to do great work and spur each other on to solve the challenges faced by the company. Creating opportunities for employees creates an atmosphere where people feel valued, which in turn helps them produce their best work.
Lesson 3: Invest the Time To Truly Understand the Cultural Context
Upon reading the case study, what is clear is that Ghosn had a genuinely open mind when it came to understanding Japanese culture. He consciously blocked any preconceived notions or ideas about how Japanese people carry themselves and arrived with a desire to understand the traditions that underpinned so much of the culture of Nissan.
One of the three multicultural competencies is the ability to be culturally sensitive. Part of that journey is moving from an ethnocentric attitude towards culture and transitioning into an ethnorelative attitude towards culture. Ghosn embodied an ethnorelative ethos that freed him from the idea that cultures fit into a hierarchy. He actively sought to understand both French culture and Japanese culture and looked for a way to build a relationship between them.
Approaching these matters with such a positive attitude meant that he was able to get two seemingly incompatible cultures on board and push both Nissan and Renault towards an outcome that was mutually beneficial. Global leaders should never underestimate the impact their attitude towards culture has on their ability to effectively lead people; the wrong attitude will have you alienating people before you’ve had an opportunity to even suggest an idea.
Lesson 4: Ensure that the Vision is Clear
Ghosn had a clear vision to make Nissan profitable again. He wanted to do that by cutting costs, making internal processes more efficient and championing an innovative spirit that would carry Nissan forward into a new age. The vision was easy for everybody at all levels of the company to understand and so it was far easier for everybody to collaborate on its execution.
Global leaders must ensure that the vision is well defined; so well defined in fact that the employees and management can envisage how their role fits into the fulfillment of that vision. It is difficult for collaboration to exist in an environment of confusion. This is one of the most powerful lessons a global leader can take away from Ghson’s management style.
Another point to note is that the case study covers two periods of transition, with two different visions. The first part of the vision was to make Nissan profitable. Then when Nissan hit that target a year earlier than expected, Ghosn was ready with another vision that the whole company could transition into. This kept the Nissan wheels in motion and had the whole company moving from strength to strength as they innovated new products and increased their overall market share.
As we all know, “a rolling stone gathers no moss.” Global leaders must be forward thinkers. When the vision is complete, there must be another waiting in the wings that the workforce can get behind. It defines what it means to be a dynamic global leader; you keep your team excited and ready for the next challenge.
Lesson 5: Match the Vision with A Story
Storytelling is a powerful part of the human experience and an invaluable tool for all leaders who wish to inspire others into action. Ghosn did this perfectly to help the Nissan workforce understand why change was necessary. One of the issues that Ghosn faced was the ingrained complacency at Nissan. A complacent attitude halted innovation and a desire to become more efficient. The cars being produced by Nissan were reliable but had an outdated design. The cost of production was kept high by the commitment to the keiretsu preferred suppliers list which ate into profitability. Underpinning all of this was the belief that if things were to go sour financially, the Japanese government, in an effort to preserve people’s employment, would bail Nissan out.
Very conveniently at the time Ghosn took over the operations at Nissan and masterminded the merger with Renault, a large Japanese corporation got into financial trouble and was not bailed out by the Japanese government. This sent shockwaves through everyone at Nissan; Ghosn used this story to kickstart their creativity and create a healthy sense of urgency. If they themselves did not do all they could to turn the fortunes of this billion-dollar company around, there was no bailout coming. Nissan would close and all of their jobs would close with it.
By pairing a clear vision with a powerful story that is relevant to all, Ghosn created the optimal environment for a typically tenacious culture to become fluid and adaptable again. The lesson for global leaders is as follows; use a story to show people why they should get behind the vision. A vision without a clear reason why can be ignored. But if as a global leader, you take the time to find a reason that’s motivating enough, any culture can be molded and shaped differently.
Lesson 6: Create a Collaborative Culture
Global leaders recognize that they cannot achieve everything on their own. Creating an atmosphere of collaboration and ownership creates a perfect environment for creativity. In addition to this, the satisfaction that comes from each employee knowing that their contribution, however small, has an impact. Being a part of such an electric environment stimulates the workforce into giving their best, with everybody moving towards a common goal.
Ghosn did this exceedingly well. As a global leader, the aim should always be to draw teams closer together to maximize innovation and productivity. It also makes for a far more efficient way of delivering change. So efficient, you can over-deliver on your goals; Nissan became profitable one year earlier than planned because people began to work together so effectively.
Global Leaders Wear the Biggest Shoes
Fast forward to today and it’s easy to see the lasting effect that true global leadership has. Carlos Ghosn has been removed from his position and the void that has been left is evident. Nissan continues to fight declining sales and profitability. Management has yet to deliver a clear vision, the partnership between Renault and Nissan is now in jeopardy with leaders at the top of the organization resorting to threatening one another around stocks and shares.
It’s a far cry from the spirit of collaboration and innovation fostered by Ghosn in decades past. For aspiring global leaders, Carlos’ example is noteworthy because it shows the impact of successful global leadership in action; a living embodiment of what is truly possible in this sphere of leadership.
We hope you were able to gain some insight from this example of successful global leadership against all odds, despite the negative media currently surrounding Mr. Ghosn. The situation today should not take away from your possibility to learn from this case study.
To find out more about how you can become the most impactful global leader you can be, have a look to see how the Eurac Academy can help you to reach those goals. To continue to receive a goldmine of global leadership wisdom straight into your inbox, don’t forget to sign up for our weekly newsletter!